Skip to content

Decision log

Date Decision Detail
2026-11-14 Harvest (2026-10-10 to 2026-11-14) Updated aspnet-core-security.md (refresh token families, and a token_version check), aspnet-core.md (localized validation messages), runtime-performance.md (FileOptions.Asynchronous, and a runtime async migration order), and ui-frameworks.md (the UIKit scene lifecycle for Xcode 27). Fixed or dropped the unsupported claims that #238 reports, in 13 opinions and 5 templates. Flagged ardalis, nicholas-blumhardt, scott-wlaschin, and stephen-cleary
2026-11-14 Let a reference support a reference fact alone (no roster change) A reference fact is a statement about a reference's own subject that a reader can check against it, including what the subject requires of a project that uses it. It needs no roster source. A choice or a judgement still rests on one. The shared admission criteria define the terms. The maintainer's decision, in awesome-humans/website#188
2026-10-23 Watch-listed ms-dotnet-skills The .NET team's skill pack, first published 2026-02-03, so short of two years. Re-evaluate from 2028-02, and check its MSTest steer then
2026-10-23 Watch-listed ms-aspire-skills Microsoft's Aspire skill pack, first published 2026-05-08, so short of two years. Re-evaluate from 2028-05
2026-10-23 Named four repositories as references (no roster change) dotnet/csharplang, fsharp/fslang-design, dotnet/designs, and dotnet/core can corroborate a roster-sourced claim inline. Package repositories already qualify, and guidance repositories such as dotnet/skills still need vet-source
2026-10-18 Replaced the house ID with house:<profile> House opinions belong to a house profile, such as house:simon-mckenna, and the site shows a profile's only to a reader who chooses it
2026-10-17 Admitted stephen-cleary Writing on async and concurrency since 2008-06-20, with in-post corrections. Latest post 2025-12-04, so re-evaluate from 2026-12-04 if nothing follows (#167)
2026-10-09 Re-evaluated khalid (no tier change) His personal blog resumed on 2026-10-05 after a gap from 2025-04-22, which the Duende byline covered. The notes now record the restart, and a token-shape limit on citing his scope-authorization post
2026-10-09 Harvest (2026-09-15 to 2026-10-09) Updated runtime-performance.md (ILLink substitutions, and a .NET 11 runtime async note) and ci.md (signer allow-list upkeep). Flagged khalid, james-montemagno, and nicholas-blumhardt
2026-09-25 Merged dotnet-skills into aaron-stannard The same person, so his track record covers the repository. Uncompiled samples and co-authored skills became usage limits in his notes
2026-09-25 Watch-listed dotnet-skills Under a year old, with samples that don't compile against current packages, and several authors. Re-evaluate from 2027-11
2026-09-25 Admitted aaron-stannard Sixteen years of writing, with depth in code-backed engineering posts. Gave the ai-usage research topic a .NET practitioner source. Petabridge recorded as a conflict
2026-09-20 Merged Tier 1 and Tier 2 into one Citable table No skill or check treated the tiers differently. Longevity is now two years, shown by Since, and the independence cap became a usage limit in the notes. No source's citability changed
2026-09-15 Defined references (no roster change) A named package's own material can corroborate a roster-sourced claim inline, outside sources: (raised in review of #74)
2026-09-14 Harvest (2026-08-19 to 2026-09-14) Updated testing.md, ci.md, runtime-performance.md, ui-frameworks.md, fsharp.md, aspnet-core.md, and data-access.md, and gave architecture.md its unmarked corroboration. Flagged scott-wlaschin, steve-gordon, and nicholas-blumhardt
2026-09-12 Ran vet-source on the security research topic's candidates Seven checked: damien-bowden admitted, barry-dorrans watch-listed, and the OWASP Cheat Sheet Series and Philippe De Ryck declined
2026-09-12 Watch-listed scott-brady Dormant by his own statement. Last substantial article 2024-04
2026-09-12 Watch-listed duende-blog Blocked on independence and five unvetted bylines. Khalid's posts are citable under his own ID
2026-09-12 Widened khalid to his Duende writing (no tier change) His bylined Duende posts come into scope. Never cite him alone on adopting a Duende product
2026-09-12 Watch-listed barry-dorrans Blog only since 2025-11-18. Strong writing recorded in the notes. Re-evaluate from 2027-11
2026-09-12 Admitted damien-bowden (Tier 1) Writing since 2013-01-31. The BFF and browser-authentication depth source the security research topic lacked
2026-09-10 Admitted ardalis (Tier 1, marked Corroborate.) Writing since 2003, including DevIQ and his documentation. Marked for mixed depth. Conflict recorded
2026-09-04 Named the date field in the ms-learn citation rule (no tier change) A research pass quoted updated_at, a build timestamp, and got six dates wrong. The rule now names ms.date
2026-09-03 Ran an admission pass for opinions/architecture.md Added mark-seemann as the unmarked design source the file lacked
2026-09-03 Admitted derek-comartin (Tier 1, marked Corroborate.) The blog clears the writing scope by itself. Marked for having no code or measurements, and for sponsorship in the article body
2026-09-03 Admitted jeremy-miller (Tier 1, marked Corroborate.) Writing since 2007, almost only about the stack his company sells
2026-09-03 Admitted mark-seemann (Tier 1) Twenty years of writing, with depth you can verify in code and measurements. Conflict recorded
2026-08-24 Widened ms-learn across learn.microsoft.com (no tier change) Took in the Azure Architecture Center. Cite it for mechanism and trade-offs, with each page's review date
2026-08-24 Watch-listed udi-dahan Dormant since 2016-02-19, with no continuing written channel
2026-08-24 Admitted oskar-dudycz (Tier 1, marked Corroborate.) Sustained output from 2020. Filled the event-driven and vertical-slice gaps. Conflict recorded
2026-08-23 Re-vetted james-montemagno and shay-rojansky on writing alone (no tier changes) Montemagno is citable before 2024 only. Rojansky is held on his EF Core documentation
2026-08-23 Demoted nick-polyak to the watch list (was Tier 1) No writing since 2025-05-04. His two ui-frameworks.md citations moved to the Avalonia docs
2026-08-23 Replaced the depth cap with the **Corroborate.** marking code-with-mukesh moves to Tier 1, marked. CI rejects an opinion whose only citable source is marked
2026-08-23 Re-verified nicholas-blumhardt under the new rule (no tier change) The Datalust blog alone holds the exception
2026-08-23 Ruled that repository activity isn't evidence of a live source Commits and releases don't keep a dormant source admitted. Documentation written in a repository does
2026-08-23 Removed steve-sanderson (was Tier 1) Stood on talks and repositories, which the narrowed scope excludes. Never cited
2026-08-23 Narrowed scope to published writing Video, talks, and podcasts no longer count, as citations or as track record
2026-08-23 Removed nick-chapsas (was Tier 2) Never cited, and his notes already said to cite the primary source instead
2026-08-23 Clarified that the watch list never feeds sources: Back catalogue included, as validate-sources.cs enforces. A demotion re-sources or drops its claims in the same pull request
2026-08-21 Admitted shay-rojansky (Tier 2) Filled the .NET to PostgreSQL gap. Capped for independence. Dormant since 2023-05, admitted on the exception
2026-08-20 Widened avalonia-blog to the project docs (no tier change) Gave the Avalonia localization mechanism a citable home. Same publisher, same cap
2026-08-18 Re-evaluated khalid, nick-polyak, and james-montemagno (no tier changes) Narrowed the notes for all three
2026-08-18 Demoted morning-brew (Tier 1 to watch list) Last issue 2024-08-02. An aggregator has no second channel for the dormancy exception
2026-08-18 Admitted jon-skeet (Tier 1) Publishing since 2005-09. Filled the records and immutable-collection gaps
2026-08-18 Harvest (2026-08-13 to 2026-08-18), plus a first sweep of nicholas-blumhardt and jon-skeet Updated testing.md, runtime-performance.md, and csharp.md, and opened logging.md. Flagged james-montemagno, nick-polyak, and khalid
2026-08-17 Admitted nicholas-blumhardt (Tier 1) Publishing since 2007-07. Personal blog dormant since 2024-10, held on the Datalust engineering series. Sells Seq, recorded as a conflict
2026-08-17 Experiment: Tier 1 from 6 years to 5, and Tier 2 from 3 years to a 2-to-5-year band No roster changes: every blocked row is blocked on something other than longevity
2026-08-14 Harvest of newly admitted sources (2025-11-01 to 2026-08-14) Added Avalonia 12 to ui-frameworks.md, and opened architecture.md and data-access.md
2026-08-14 Kept 4 of 10 watch-list rows chris-sainty and mikesdotnetting on dormancy, and telerik-blog and syncfusion-blog on independence and depth
2026-08-14 Admitted avalonia-blog (Tier 2) Its 2022 start clears the 3-year bar. Capped for independence as a product-team blog
2026-08-14 Admitted code-with-mukesh (Tier 2) Blog since 2020. Capped on depth as SEO-shaped and course-funnelled
2026-08-14 Admitted nick-chapsas (Tier 2) Capped on depth: trend-driven video, with courses over the same ground (removed 2026-08-23)
2026-08-14 Admitted awesome-avalonia (Tier 1, discovery-only) Created 2020-02, which the new bar clears
2026-08-14 Admitted csharp-digest (Tier 1, discovery-only) Archive verified back to 2017-12
2026-08-14 Admitted milan-jovanovic (Tier 1) Started about 2020, weekly through 2026-08. Conflict of interest recorded, not capped
2026-08-14 Promoted awesome-blazor (Tier 2 to Tier 1, discovery-only) Curated since 2018
2026-08-14 Promoted jetbrains-dotnet (Tier 2 to Tier 1) Publishing since the early 2010s. The language explainers keep critical distance
2026-08-14 Promoted andrew-lock and steve-gordon (Tier 2 to Tier 1) Both publishing since about 2016
2026-08-14 Experiment: lowered the longevity bars Tier 1 from about a decade to 6 years, and Tier 2 from 8 years to 3. The rows below follow from re-running vet-source and harvest-sources
2026-08-12 Reserved the house ID The maintainer's own opinions, exempt from admission and always visibly marked (#7)
2026-08-12 Updated the steve-gordon note Publishing again from 2026-01
2026-08-12 Corrected the scott-wlaschin harvest flag Low cadence, not dormant: the sweep missed his 2025-12 posts
2026-08-12 Annotated khalid (kept Tier 1) Blog quiet since 2025-04. Kept on GitHub activity, a basis withdrawn on 2026-08-23
2026-08-12 Demoted mikesdotnetting (Tier 1 to watch list) Dormant since 2023-04, with no continuing channel
2026-08-12 First harvest (2025-11-01 to 2026-08-12) Seeded 8 opinion files. Flagged mikesdotnetting, khalid, and scott-wlaschin for vet-source
2026-08-12 Watch-listed awesome-avalonia Created 2020-02, short of the eight-year discovery bar then in force (admitted 2026-08-14)
2026-08-12 Admitted nick-polyak (Tier 1) Publishing since 2008 on CodeProject, then Dev.to (demoted 2026-08-23)
2026-08-12 Watch-listed avalonia-blog Blog only since about 2022, short on longevity (admitted 2026-08-14)
2026-08-12 Watch-listed chris-sainty Strong 2018 to 2023 Blazor catalogue, dormant since 2023-08
2026-08-12 Admitted awesome-blazor (Tier 2, discovery-only) Curated list since 2018, actively maintained
2026-08-12 Admitted gerald-versluis (Tier 2) Blogging since 2015-03. Capped for independence as a MAUI team member
2026-08-12 Admitted james-montemagno (Tier 2) Blogging since about 2012. Capped for independence as Microsoft developer relations
2026-08-12 Admitted steve-sanderson (Tier 1) Blog dormant since 2020-01. Admitted on talks and repositories under the dormancy exception (removed 2026-08-23)
2026-08-12 Admitted scott-wlaschin and fsharp-weekly (Tier 1) Filled the F# gap. Writing since 2012 and 2011
2026-08-12 Initial roster Seeded Tier 1, Tier 2, and the watch list from research verified against .NET 10